Regional Head Elections by the People's Representative Council: A Critical Analysis of Constitutionality and Democratic Backsliding

Mawardi Mawardi; Yudhi Hertanto; Patawari Patawari; Jusuf Luturmas; Karman Jaya

doi:10.55227/ijhess.v5i5.2149

Authors

Mawardi Mawardi Institut Bahri Asyiq Galis Bangkalan
Yudhi Hertanto Universitas Islam Sultan Agung
Patawari Patawari Universitas Indonesia Timur
Jusuf Luturmas Universitas Lelemuku Saumlaki
Karman Jaya Universitas Handayani Makassar

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.55227/ijhess.v5i5.2149

Keywords:

Regional Head Elections, DPRD, Constitution, Democracy, Democratic Backsliding.

Abstract

The election of regional heads constitutes a fundamental mechanism for the realization of popular sovereignty and the implementation of decentralization at the local level. Since the post-reform era, the direct election of regional leaders by citizens has been widely regarded as a significant achievement in strengthening local democracy in Indonesia. Nevertheless, the re-emergence of discourse advocating the election of regional heads by Regional People’s Representative Councils (DPRD) has sparked intense debate, particularly from constitutional law and contemporary democratic theory perspectives. This article aims to critically examine the election of regional heads by DPRD by assessing its compatibility with constitutional principles and analyzing its implications within the framework of democratic backsliding. The research employs normative legal methods, utilizing statutory, conceptual, and comparative approaches. The findings indicate that although the election of regional heads by DPRD may formally satisfy procedural democratic requirements, such a mechanism carries a substantial risk of weakening substantive democracy. This is evidenced by the reduction of direct public participation, the increasing influence of political elites and oligarchic structures, and the shift of accountability from the electorate to local legislative bodies. Furthermore, this mechanism is considered inconsistent with the spirit of Article 18 paragraph (4) of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, which emphasizes the democratic election of regional leaders. Therefore, any alteration to the regional head election system must be approached with caution to ensure that it does not become a vehicle for democratic regression, but rather contributes to the enhancement of legitimacy, public participation, and the overall quality of local democracy.

References

Abdussamad, G. M. A., Faralita, E., & Sulastri. (2023). Korupsi politik terlahir dari sistem pemilihan umum menggunakan sistem proporsional terbuka di indonesia. 11(2337), 62–77.

Adji, A. B., Mau, H. A., & Candra, M. (2024). Konstitusionalitas Perubahan Usia Calon Presiden Dan Calon Wakil Presiden Dalam Negara Hukum Demokrasi. Sentri: Jurnal Riset Ilmiah, 3(1), 16–25.

Aspinall, E., Fossati, D., Muhtadi, B., & Warburton, E. (2020). Elites, masses, and democratic decline in Indonesia. Democratization, 27(4), 505–526. https://doi.org/10.1080/13510347.2019.1680971

Darmawan, & Muchlisin. (2025). Rekonstruksi Hukum Pemilihan Umum Daerah Pasca Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi. Jurnal Terapan Hukum Islam Dan Kajian Filsafat Syariah, 2(3), 56–74.

Fikri, A. F., Tikoto, A. H. A., & Afrianto. (2025). Disharmonisasi Kepala Daerah dan Wakilnya di Indonesia : Literatur Review. Jurnal Pemerintahan Dan Kebijakan (Jpk), 6(2), 92–106. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.18196/jpk.v6i2.24088

Fikry, A. H. Al. (2022). Diskursus Prinsip Negara Hukum Demokrasi atas Permasalahan Konstitusionalitas Undang-Undang Nomor 3 Tahun 2022 tentang Ibu Kota Negara. Jurnal Hukum Lex Generalis, 3(8), 609–619.

Gunawan, S. Q., & Muslim, J. (2025). Menakar Kualitas Demokrasi dalam Pelaksanaan Pilkada 2024 di Kecamatan Cibitung Kabupaten Bekasi. Gunung Djati Conference Series, 50, 199–206.

Hadiz, V. R. (2010). Localising power in post-authoritarian Indonesia : A Southeast Asia perspective. Stanford California.

Iqball, L. M. R., Rusnan, & Koynja, J. J. (2025). Konstitusionalitas Ambang Batas Calon Kepala Daerah Dan Calon Wakil Kepala Daerah Berdasarkan Prinsip Demokrasi. Jurnal Diskresi, 4(2), 294–302.

Levitsky, S., & Ziblatt, D. (2024). How democracies die. In Ideals and Ideologies (pp. 73-80). : Routledge.

Mahardika, A. G., & Fatayati, S. (2020). Penerapan Pilkada Asimetris Sebagai Upaya Menciptakan Sistem Pemerintahan Daerah Yang Efektif. Indonesia Journal Of Humanities and Social Sciences, 1(1), 50–67.

Mietzner, M. (2020). Authoritarian innovations in Indonesia: electoral narrowing, identity politics and executive illiberalism. Democratization, 27(6), 1021–1036. https://doi.org/10.1080/13510347.2019.1704266

Muslih, M. (2014). Reorientasi dan Reformulasi Sistem Pemilihan Kepala Daerah Menuju Pemilihan Kepala Daerah yang Berorientasi pada Nilai Keadilan dan Keseimbangan (Kebijakan Pemilihan Kepala Daerah yang Didasarkan pada Nilai-nilai Pancasila). Lex Specialist, 20, 122–139.

Putnam, R. D. (1993). Making democracy work: Civic traditions in modern Italy. Princeton University Press.

Rahayu, D. P., & Sulaiman. (2020). Metode penelitian hukum. Yogyakarta : Penerbit Thafa Media.

Ridua, S. M. (2025). Pemilihan Kepala Daerah Melalui DPRD Dalam Sistem Ketatanegaraan Indonesia. Honeste Vivere Journal, 35(2), 206–216.

Riskiyono, J. (2019). Kedaulatan Partisipasi Pemilih dalam Pengawasan Pemilihan Kepala Daerah dan Pemilihan Umum Serentak 2019. Politicia, 10(2), 145–165.

Riyanti, R., & Firmanto, F. (2025). Pemilihan Kepala Daerah Melalui Pemilihan DPRD Berbasis Demokrasi Perwakilan. Jurnal Pengabdian Masyarakat Dan Riset Pendidikan, 4(1), 3946–3953. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.31004/jerkin.v4i1.2227

Rohmah, E. I. (2024). Perubahan Paradigma Politik di Indonesia Dari Demokrasi ke Oligarki : Telaah Pemikiran W . A . Bonger. Politeia : Jurnal Ilmu Politik, 16(01), 1–12.

Sahibuddin, A. (2025). Implementasi putusan mahkamah konstitusi nomor 60/puu-xxii/2024 dan pengaruhnya terhadap demokrasi pemilihan kepala daerah tahun 2024.

Satria, N., & Chahnia, J. (2025). Politik Hukum dalam Menetukan Arah Perubahan Mekanisme Pemilihan Kepala Daerah di Indonesia. Jurnal Hukum Pidana Dan Ketatanegaraan Islam, 15(1).

Sihombing, D. N. (2025). Pemakzulan Dalam Demokrasi Presidensial Indonesia : Antara Legalitas Konstitusional dan Legitimasi Politik. Jurnal Nawala Politika, 3(1), 35–56.

Susanto, S., Abra, E. H., & Hadiyanto, A. (2025). Dinamika Politik Identitas Dalam Pemilu 2024 : Tantangan Bagi Konsolidasi Demokrasi di Indonesia. Jurnal Usm Law Review, 8(3), 1506–1518.

Ulum, M. B. (2021). Pemilihan Kepala Daerah di Indonesia Setelah Reformasi : Kesinambungan dan Perubahan. Jurnal Hukum, 4(2), 309–343. https://doi.org/10.22437/ujh.4.2.309-343

Zulkifli, M. A., Wahdah, N. Al, & Dantye, F. (2025). Pilkada Kota Pangkalpinang 2024 : Analisis Kritis Partisipasi Masyarakat dalam Perspektif Sosial dan Hukum. Unes Journal of Swara Justisia, 9(2), 289–299.